SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

vol.43 número4Comparison of Phenotypic and Genetic Performance of Local Silkworm Groups and Two Commercial LinesToxicity mechanisms of onion (Allium cepa) extracts and compounds in multidrug resistant erythroleukemic cell line índice de autoresíndice de materiabúsqueda de artículos
Home Pagelista alfabética de revistas  

Servicios Personalizados




Links relacionados


Biological Research

versión impresa ISSN 0716-9760

Biol. Res. v.43 n.4 Santiago  2010 

Biol Res 43: 417-427, 2010



Anatomical root variations in response to water deficit: wild and domesticated common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L)


Cecilia B. Peña-Valdivia1*, Adriana B. Sánchez-Urdaneta2, Joel Meza Rangel3, Juana Juárez Muñoz3, Rodolfo García-Nava1 and Raquel Celis Velázquez1

1  Botánica, Colegio de Postgraduados. Km 35.5 Carretera Mexico-Texcoco, Montecillo, Mexico, 56230. Mexico.
2  Facultad de Agronomía, Universidad del Zulia, Av. Ziruma, Maracaibo, Venezuela.
3  Instituto de Ciencias Agropecuarias de la Universidad Autónoma del Estado de Hidalgo. Rancho Universitario s/n, Exhacienda de Aquetzalpa. Tulancingo, Hgo.


Root anatomical responses to water deficit are diverse and regulation of water uptake strongly depends on plant anatomy. The ancestors of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) cultivars are the wild common beans. Because wild beans adapt and survive well in theon atural environment, it is hypothesized that wild common bean roots are less affected than those of domesticated beans at low substrate water potential (ψW). A wild common bean accession from Chihuahua Mexico and cv. Bayomex were studied. Seedlings with a mean root length between 3 and 4 cm were maintained for 24 h in vermiculite at ψW of -0.03 (well hydrated), -0.65, -1.48 and -2.35 MPa (partially dry). Ten anatomical characteristics of differentiation and cell division in root regions were evaluated. Thickness of epidermis and protoderm diminished similarly in wild and domesticated beans growing at low substrate ψW (between -0.65 and -2.35 MPa). At the same time, parenchymatic cell area diminished by 71 % in the domesticated variety, but by only 32 % in the wild bean at -2.35 MPa. Theon umber of cells in the cortex and the thickness of the xylem wall increased in both wild and domesticated beans at low substrate ψW;on evertheless, the effect was significantly lower in the wild bean. Theon umber of xylem vessels increased in the cultivar (up to 40 %) while in the wild bean it decreased (up to 33 %). The diameter of xylem vessels and transverse root area diminished (15 and 57 %, respectively) in the cultivar, but in the wild common bean wereon ot affected. Anatomical root characteristics and their modifications in both differentiation and cell division in root regions demonstrated that the wild bean reacted quite differently to substrate ψW than the domesticated common bean.

Key terms: Endodermis, protoderm, seedlings, water potential, xylem.


The importance of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) throughout the world is remarkable. By 2007 dry beans were grown on 28.2 million ha, in 120 countries, with a total production of 20.1 million tons (FAO,; February 14, 2010). In addition, the common bean is the most important grain legume for direct human consumption in the developing world, mainly because it is a major source of low cost protein. Drought is a major constraint to common bean production in many countries. The common bean is highly susceptible to drought stress. Depending on the severity of the water deficit, drought affects the plant directly by dehydration, and indirectly, by reducingon utrient absorption (Hose et al., 2001). The common bean is cultivated in regions where water deficits can significantly reduce growth and yield. Drought affects global common bean production by 60 % (Teran and Singh, 2002; Urrea et al., 2009). Consequently, there are efforts to obtain drought resistant P. vulgaris cultivars (Urrea et al., 2009). The ancestors of common bean cultivars are the wild common beans; Mexico is one of the two centers of origin and has a great diversity of wild bean populations. Domestication favored anthropocentric features like larger seeds, loss of dehiscence, loss of dormancy, reducing or eliminating anti-physiological factors, and others like increased seed color diversity or culinary features, yet it seems these were trade-off features associated with the cultivation environment. It has been observed that some wild populations are tolerant to low substrate water potential Oí\v)/ probably because ofon atural adaptation to semi-arid conditions. Consequently, wild beans could be a good source of genetic pools to improve current common bean cultivars (Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2003 and 2004a; Arroyo-Peña et al., 2005).

Given the above, it is very important to understand the anatomical, biochemical and physiological response of the common bean to drought, especially under the effects of climatic change and in the context of food security issues (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2007a-b). A mayor benefit of wild type usage is enhanced biological diversity and richness without the transgenic of highly mechanized agricultural processes, considering the relevance of this seed for developing countries where agriculture is less technology-intensive.

The anatomical responses of plants to water deficit are diverse and depend on adaptive characteristics expressed through diverse mechanisms. Roots can be compared to sensors that detect changes in soil ψW through tissue dehydration and play an important role in plant resistance to water deficit (Shao et al., 2008). The root anatomy of plants growing under water deficit is still only partially known, mainly because of the difficulty of obtaining intact roots and the root-to-shoot interaction during development. However, it has been documented that changes in the anatomy of root tissue result from modérate or high water deficit. These are adaptive strategies of plants to survive in adverse environments (Shao et al., 2008).

Young seedlings with undeveloped shoots of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) (Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2003 and 2004a), maize (Zea mays L.) (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005; Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2005) and maguey (Agave salmiana) (Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2004b; Peña-Valdivia and Sánchez-Urdaneta, 2009) have been used to study root reaction to substrate ψW - For instance, when comparing drought sensitive and drought tolerant maize cultivars, it has been observed that root seedlings growing at substrate ψW of -2.35 MPa decreased transverse root area, thickness of epidermis, exodermis and cortex, and theon umber of cells in the cortex and metaxylem vessels compared to seedlings growing at -0.03 MPa. However, protoderm and cortex thickness were affected only in the drought sensitive maize (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005). Some of the above root anatomical responses seem to be adaptations that enhance plant survival in hostile environments (Da Silva et al., 2003).

The aim of this research was to evaluate anatomical changes in root seedlings of a wild accession and a cultivar of common bean (P. vulgaris L.) under different substrate ψW and in laboratory growth conditions, in order to test the hypothesis that roots of the wild common bean are less affected than the domesticated type at low ψW.


Plant Material

The cv. Bayomex and a wild common bean accession (P. vulgaris L.) from Chihuahua, Mexico, were evaluated. They were chosen because contrasting reactions to low substrate ψW in root seedlings have been reported, taking into account growth, relative water content, damage index of cellular membranes, and electrolyte leakage (Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2003 and 2004a).

The cv. Bayomex was developed by the INIFAP (National Institute for Research in Agriculture, Forestry and Animal Husbandry, Mexico) for cultivation in dry land areas. Wild seeds (accession G22837 coded at the International Centre of Tropical Agriculture) were originally collected from Chihuahua, Mexico (26°56' Lat.on , 106°25' Long. E, 1750 m.a.s.L, and BSlkw (w)(e') climate or semidry temperate climate). Seeds were multiplied in an experimental field at the Colegio de Postgraduados in Montecillo, Mexico (19°31' Lat.on , 98°53' Long. W and 2353 m.a.s.L), during the spring-summer season and were kept refrigerated at 5 ± 1 °C and 20 % RH for several days until the research began.

Experimental design and statistical analysis

The experiment was conducted with a completely random design with a factorial treatment arrangement. Evaluated factors and levels were: common bean type (wild and domesticated) and substrate ψW (-0.03, -0.65, -1.48 and -2.35 MPa). Each experimental unit was a group of seven seedlings, three sub-samples were obtained from each root, and the experiment was replicated four times. Data were submitted to an analysis of variance, mean múltiple comparisons with Tukey's HSD test and Pearson correlation test. As well, a principal components multivariable analysis was carried out to identify which variables were the most important to describe the effects of ψW on root anatomy. Statistical analysis was performed with SAS software (SAS Institute, 1999-2000, version 8.1). Data graphic representation was obtained using the SigmaPlot software (Jandel Scientific, version 9). The GenStat for Teaching software (VSN International Ltd) was used to investígate the linear regression relationship between root anatomical characteristics and ψW.


Seeds were germinated at 25 ± 1 °C in darkness as described by Peña-Valdivia et al. (2002). Root seedling length, after 72 h of germination, was between 30 and 40 mm. In order to quantify root growth during theon ext 24-48 h, a mark was made 2 mm over the apex with a paintbrush and black ink, since longitudinal root growth of the common bean mainly occurs in the first 2 mm from the apex (Garcia-Nava et al., 1999). Seedlings were then transplanted into polyvinyl-chloride containers (40 mm inside diameter and 100 mm length) filled with vermiculite at different ψW. Each container was covered with a removable black polyethylene lid, fixed with an elastic band in order to keep a constant ψW. All procedures were carried out in darkness. Containers were then maintained in dark conditions at 25 + 1 °C for 24 h, roots were then harvested and anatomical characteristics were evaluated.

Vermiculite at ψW of -0.03, -0.65, -1.48 and -2.35 MPa was obtained by mixing dry vermiculite with 100, 10, 8 and 6 parts of distilled water (w:v) respectively, and then maintained in polyethylene bags for a period of 48 h before the start of the experiment. After this time, each vermiculite ψW was determined using psychrometric chambers (Wescon C-52, Inc, Utha, USA) during 4 h; vermiculite ψW was determined by connecting the chambers to a microvoltmeter (Wescon HR-33T, Inc, Utha, USA) operated in the dew point mode (Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2005).

Anatomical characteristics were evaluated in two root sections, the first centimetre of the root apex, including the cell division root region, and an upper section, the differentiation root region. Tissues were fixed in an acetic acid:formaldehyde:ethanol:water solution (FAA, 5:10:52:33), in a 10:1 (w:v) fixensample relation, for a 4 to 6 d period, and then dehydrated with butyl alcohol, followed by embedding in paraffin. Samples were sectioned into 10 um ribbons and mounted on glass slides with chrome adhesive. Staining was made using a safranin-fast green stain system following Johansen (1974, cited by Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005). The observation and analysis of preparations were conducted in an inverted optimum microscope (ZEISS, Axiovert 25), equipped with a video camera (SONY SSC-DC54). Dimensions andon umber of anatomical structures (transverse root area, parenchymatic cell area, xylem vessel diameter, thickness of protoderm, thickness of epidermis, thickness of xylem wall, parenchymatic cellon umber and xylem vesselon umber) were obtained from images captured with a video camera using the Image Tool 3.0 software for PC (Wilcox et al., 2002).


Research and practices aimed at improving water-stress resistance and water-use efficiency in plants have been carried out for many years, yet the plant mechanism involved is stillon ot clear. Knowledge of the biochemical, molecular and morphological responses to drought is essential for a holistic interpretation of the resistance mechanisms to water-limited conditions in higher plants (Shao et al., 2008). Among the main functions roots perform ison utrient uptake from the soil. Proper root performance relies on certain specialized cortical layers (e.g. the endodermis and exodermis act as ions filters) (Ma and Peterson, 2003). Water deficit triggers a wide variety of root responses, so that changes in root growth can explain alterations in cellular metabolism and plant productivity. Plants growth and hydraulic changes can be understood by better knowing anatomical root modifications. In our view, there is insufficient information about the changes in root anatomical as reaction to water deficit (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005; Peña-Valdivia and Sánchez-Urdaneta, 2009).

Transverse root area

The transverse root section was circular in both wild and domesticated common beans only at -0.03 MPa (fully hydrated substrate). It ison oteworthy that at this ψW the transverse root area of the domesticated bean was significantly higher compared to that of the wild bean (between 31 and 93 % in differentiation and cell division root regions, respectively). Low substrate ψWon egatively affected the transverse root area, mostly at the differentiation region in both common beans. This effect was different between domesticated and wild bean, since only in the former the change followed a linear decay (y=0.15x + 0.07, R2=0.61, P< 0.01) (Figure 1 A). The lowest ψW (-2.35 MPa; partially hydrated substrate, 6 % water) diminished by 57 % transverse root area at the differentiation region of domesticated bean; in contrast, the reduction in wild bean averaged 31 %, at this ψW. Both beans reached a similar transverse root area (0.4 mm2). The transverse root area of the cell division region was less affected at lower ψW (up to 26 %) than the differentiation region in the domesticated bean; in contrast, the wild bean wason ot affected. These observations demónstrate that transverse root growth of the wild bean was less and differently affected than the domesticated bean by low substrate ψW. This could be the result of wild bean adaptation to adverse environments, including low water availability because of erratic precipitation and/or water competition withon eighboring vegetation. The result is that wild beans seem more tolerant to water deficit than the domesticated ones (Sánchez-Urdaneta et al., 2004 b; Arroyo-Peña et al., 2005). An irregular transverse root shape (compare Figure 2 A-B and 3 A-B to 2 D-E and 3 D-E), with a smaller area, was observed with all ψW lower than -0.03 MPa.

In the present study, the highest reaction to low substrate ψW of differentiation root region with respect to cell division was observed in the transverse root area; this was also observed in maize seedling roots of cv. Tuxpeño C0 and Tuxpeño C8, drought sensitive and tolerant, respectively (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005). This can be interpreted as a seedling root reaction to low substrate ψW representing a strategy that is widespread among higher plant species.

Root epidermis and protoderm

Epidermis thickness was statistically similar in both wild and domesticated beans at -0.03 MPa. The epidermis is the outermost root layer, where water andon on-selective mineral intake can potentially move apoplastically through its walls (Hose et al., 2001). This area absorbs water from the soil in mature and still young parts of the root (North and Peterson, 2005). Low substrate ψW affected epidermis thickness similarly and with the same intensity in both cultivar and wild accession. A linear relationship between epidermis thickness and ψW was observed in both cultivar (y=10.67x+39.88, R2=0.70, P< 0.01) and wild bean (y=48.32x+11.44, R2=0.74, P<0.01), both diminished up to 35 % at the lowest substrate ψW (Figure 1 B). A similar reaction was observed in maize and maguey (monocot species) root seedlings independently of drought tolerance (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005; Peña-Valdivia and Sánchez-Urdaneta, 2009). Thus, epidermis root reaction to low substrate ψW is similar in both monocots and dicots (as in wild and domesticated beans).

The protoderm (thin outer layer of the growing points of the root that gives rise to the epidermis) in the domesticated bean reached higher (35 %) radial growth than in the wild bean at -0.03 MPa. A similaron egative linear relationship was observed between protoderm thickness and substrate ψW m both domesticated and wild beans (y = 10.66x +39.88, R2=0.87; and y =8.80 x + 37.98, R2=0.75, P<0.01, respectively). The most remarkable decrease in protoderm thickness (57 %) was at -2.35 MPa, in both beans, and likewise with the epidermis. A significant interaction (P=0.0001) between ψW and bean type, in both epidermis and protoderm thickness, confirmed the anatomical modifications in both structures regardless of bean type. Epidermis and protoderm thickness in wild bean roots were significantly similar at each substrate ψW - In contrast, the protoderm in the cultivar roots was wider than the epidermis, although the difference was almost constant independent of the substrate ψW (Figure 1B). In recent research we have found that seedling protoderm thickness was affected by low substrate ψW m a drought sensitive maize cultivar (Tuxpeño Seq. C0), whileon o changes occurred in a drought tolerant one (Tuxpeño Seq. C8) (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005). On other hand, in plants characterized as drought tolerant, such as maguey, the effect of low substrate ψW on protoderm thickness is insignificant (Peña-Valdivia and Sánchez-Urdaneta, 2009). Once again, these results indicate that this type of protoderm alteration is part of a drought tolerance strategy.

Root epidermis and protoderm showed stratification (i.e. deposition of material in successive cell wall layers, thus giving rise to a stratified appearance) in both bean types. Large intercellular spaces suggest that gas exchange is critical in this area for respiration (Figures 2 B and E, 3 B and E). In both root regions, mostly at low ψW (-2.35 MPa), cellular plasmolysis was observed, epidermal cells collapsed, and cells appeared to die in some root areas (compare Figures 2 A and 3 A, at -2.35 MPa with Figures 2 D and 3 D, at -0.03 MPa). In the present study, exodermis (the principal apoplastic barrier being located at the endodermis where the Casparian band minimizes unrestricted access of water and solutes to the stellar tissues; Hose et al., 2001) in the roots of common bean seedlings were detected closer to protoderm (Figure 2 A and D, 3 A and D).

The effects of environmental stress are determined by all plant cells, resulting in structural and functional alteration to cell integrity. Hose et al. (2001) pointed out the importance of the role short cells (passage cells) of the exodermis in the transport of materials after cellular death in the epidermis, and in cellular survival of the exodermis in some areas of the cortex and stele of onion (Allium cepa) roots after dry periods.


Only at ψW of -0.03 MPa was a typical isodiametric shape of parenchymatic cells observed in both root regions and in both wild and domesticated beans (Figure 2 A and D and 3 A and D). Modification of the isodiametric shape of parenchymatic cells was observed in dehydrated root seedlings growing under lower substrate ψW (Figure 2 A and B, 3 A and B). Similar results for maize seedling roots were reported, including reduction of cortical cell size and modification of root shape when the relative water content reached a value of 0.5 (Facette et al., 1999).

The parenchymatic cell area in the domesticated common bean was significantly larger (20.6 %) than in the wild bean at -0.03 MPa (Figure 4 A). Low ψW diminished this characteristic in both bean types, and in different proportions. The domesticated common bean was more affected than the wild one; henee the reduction in the former was substrate ψW dependent (e.g. statistically significant linear trend was detected; y = 48.32x + 11.44, R2 = 0.8156, P<0.01), and reached up to 71 % at -2.35 MPa. On the contrary, in the wild bean, it diminished only 38 % at each substrate ψW lower than -0.03 MPa (Figure 4 A). These results also indicate that roots of the domesticated common bean had more profound anatomical changes at low vermiculite ψW than did the wild common bean.

The differentiation zone of roots can be radially divided into an inner part that comprises the stele and an outer part that is defined by múltiple layers of parenchymal tissue and a single epidermal layer that conneets the root with the exterior soil environment (Saleem et al., 2010). Cortical parenchyma is the fundamental part of primary root body and represents structurally and functionally an important constituent of the root. It might serve as a storage area ofon utrients and water, and at least in younger sections of root fulfills metabolic functions that areon ot yet well understood (Lux et al., 2004; Saleem et al., 2010). As to the higher root parenchymatic cell area, at -0.03 MPa, the drastic reduction displayed by seedlings of the domesticated common bean when exposed to low substrate ψW imply an important role in determining reactions to drought in the root. The distinctive parenchymatic cell area at higher substrate ψW and theon on-linear drop of the parenchymatic cell area at low substrate ψW suggests a different drought reaction between wild root seedlings and domesticated ones.

Plasmolyzed epidermal and parenchymatic cells were observed in both division and differentiation root regions, and were more evident at ψW lower than -0.03 MPa and at -2.35 MPa (observe that plasma membrane pulled away from the cell wall in Figures 2 C and 3 C contrariwise to 2 D and 3 D). Plasmolized cells were more evident in the domesticated common bean than in the wild bean; by contrast, in the stele a similar alteration was almost imperceptible.

The lowest substrate ψW seemed to increase the parenchymatic wall thickness in both root regions, though the increase wason ot quantified. Furthermore, an almost total disconnection between adjacent cells and wide intercellular spaces was observed at -2.35 MPa (Figure 2 C and F, 3 C and F). A similar effect in the cortex of differentiation root region in drought stressed maize has beenon oted; and cortex cells of the cell division region of these roots gradually died in a centripetal pattern, and cellular distortion increased with stress, probably due to selerification (the process of changing into sclerenchyma by progressive lignification of secondary walls) of cells outside the cortex (Lux et al., 2004).

The domesticated and wild common bean had a similaron umber of cells in the cortical parenchyma in both root regions at a ψW of -0.03 MPa. Still, the root cell division region almost doubled compared to the differentiation root region (Figure 4 B). Low substrate ψW significantly increased theon umber of root cells in the cortex, although in different proportions, in both root regions of both bean types. In all cases, a statistically significant (P<0.01) linear trend was detected. In the cell division region (y=2.73x-1.19, R2=0.78) and in the differentiation region (y=1.12x-2.22, R2=0.78) the máximum increases were 2.7 and 4.4 times. In the wild common bean a less drastic increase of 1.4 and 2.3 times was obtained in the cell division root region and the differentiation root region (y=3.37x-0.90, R2=0.81 and y=1.38x-1.53, R2=0.94) respectively, at -2.35 MPa compared to -0.03 MPa (Figure 4 B). An increase in theon umber of parenchymatic cells as a reaction to low substrate ψW was evident, indicating that root tissue dehydration accelerates cellular division ; a remarkable difference is that the wild common bean reacted less drastically than the domesticated one. The increase of theon umber of cells in cortical parenchyma as a seedling reaction to low substrate ψW, like that observed in domesticated and wild common beans, has also been reported in the cell division region and differentiation region of maize and agave root seedlings (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005; Peña-Valdivia and Sánchez-Urdaneta, 2009). These results indicate that these root reactions to low substrate ψW are also a general phenomenon in seedlings of monocot and dicot species.

Endodermis and stele

In both wild and domesticated common beans, the stele in the cell division root region presented a star shape with four arms (tetrarca) branching out from a common centre, which can be surrounded by the perieyele and the endodermis. However, these two structures wereon ot clearly distinguishable, perhaps due to the immaturity of apex tissue. As well, cell layers were observed surrounding the stele (Figures 2 A and D, 3 A and D).

In the present study the endodermis and the perieyele wereon ot observed in cell division or differentiation root regions of any common bean; and intact exodermis and stele were observed only in the cell division region. In contrast, root endodermis and reduction of its thickness were clearly observed as a reaction to low substrate ψW in drought sensitive and drought tolerant maize seedlings (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005).

The functions of cortical tissues are diverse. The endodermis, and to some extent the exodermis, represents apoplastic barriers that control uptake and radial transport of water and solutes by the roots. These layers have additional functions, such as mechanically protecting the stele, as well as protecting against pathogens and parasites. The mid-cortex, or mesodermis, is the primary site for reserve material deposition. The cortex might be designated a root buffer zone, especially under stress conditions (Lux et al., 2004). For these reasons, knowing the changes oceurring in cortical tissue of wild and domesticated common beans as reaction to water deficit helps us to understand the changes oceurred during domestication.

Vascular tissue

Some anatomical characteristics related to water flow capacity and its efficient movement were quantified in the differentiation root region. Theon umber of root xylem vessels was significantly higher (40 %) in the wild common bean than in the domesticated one at ψW of -0.03 MPa. These structures increased up to 24 % at ψW of -1-48 and -2.35 MPa in the domesticated bean. In contrast, a significant reduction (33 %) was observed in theon umber of xylem vessels in the wild common bean with all substrate ψW lower than -0.03 MPa (Figure 5 A). This result could indicate that domesticated beans growing under high humidity conditions, as in an irrigated field, requires these structures less to conduct water in the plant, but under drought conditions, root xylem vessels must assure water conduction.

Different reactions to substrate ψW between the two common bean types seems to be related to the strategies of each type to the environment in which they originally grew (meaning either aon atural or agricultural environment, given the case). Theon umber and size of vascular elements, as well as theon umber and size of vascular junctions, influence water flow, potential and efficiency, as larger xylem vessels conduct water with less resistance than smaller ones (Nicotra et al., 2002). Because of these changes in the quantity of xylem vessels, they should be considered along with other root modifications as a function of substrate ψW .

Along with the above, xylem vessel diameter in the domesticated bean was 30 % larger than in the wild bean. Only in the former diameter of xylem vessels dropped significantly at low substrate ψW (up to 15 % at -2.35 MPa); in contrast, wild bean under lower than -0.03 MPa substrate ψW hadon o significant changes (Figure 5 B).

The xylem wall in domesticated bean was significantly thicker (21 %) than those in wild bean, when seedlings from both wild and domesticated beans grew in substrate at ψW of -0.03 MPa. Xylem wall thickness increased significantly, and with different intensity, in both bean types, as a reaction to low substrate ψW . Increments of xylem wall thickness reached 39 % and 16 % in domesticated and wild beans, respectively. The domesticated bean had significantly thicker xylem walls than the wild bean, independently of ψW ; the highest difference (54 %) was reached at ψW of -2.35 MPa (Figure 5C). Recently, it was observed that dry weight increases in roots of wild and domesticated common bean seedlings by the effect of restrictive ψW (Sanchez-Urdaneta et al., 2003), which can partially be explained by the growth of xylem cell walls (Facette et al., 1999).

Some substrate ψW effects seem to be common in the anatomical characteristics of roots, independent of whether they are monocot or dicot species. Like the dicot in the present study, broader xylem vessels were present in monocot root seedlings, like maize (Zea mays L.) and maguey (Agave salmiana Otto ex Salm-Dyck) (Peña-Valdivia et al., 2005; Peña-Valdivia and Sánchez-Urdaneta, 2009) with substrate ψW lower than -0.03 MPa. In contrast, other characteristics are dissimilarly affected, as is the case of xylem vessel diameter, which significantly diminished in domesticated common bean (15 %; Figure 5 B) and in cv. Tuxpeño Seq. C0 (11 %), drought-sensitive maize.on evertheless, it increased (16 %) in cv. Tuxpeño Seq. C8, drought tolerant maize, in maguey (14 %) and it wason ot modified in the wild common bean (Figure 5 B). A similar heterogeneous response was observed in theon umber of xylem vessels of 11 Australian perennial plants with phylogenetically independent contrasts (Nicotra et al., 2002).

Species living in environments where water is available might only episodically have larger xylem vessels and larger diameter roots to maximize water uptake when it is available. However, large vessels may also be more prone to cavitation and embolism during water stress (Nicotra et al., 2002). Some evidence indicate that species with inherently low relative growth rates from arid zones may have smaller vessels in their roots than in species from mesic zones (Nicotra et al., 2002).

In common beans the vascular tissue in the differentiation root region presented four fascicules, separated by inter-fascicule parenchyma (Figures 2 C and F, 3 C and F) and inter-xylem phloem; in contrast, corresponding layers belonging to endodermis, pericycle and vascular system were indistinguishable. This might be due to the development stage and/or root section observed. Substrate ψW between -0.65 and -2.35 MPa increased parenchyma cell plasmolysis of the stele, mainly at ψW of -1.48 and -2.35 MPa (compare Figures 2 and 3 B to 2 and 3 E).

Principal components multivariate analysis

To identify the variables that might be involved in the reactions of wild and domesticated common bean seedlings to substrate ψW , we carried out the multivariate data analysis of principal components, which included anatomical characteristics. The first three principal components (PC) explained 74.3 % of the variability (Table 1). The PC1 had a higher and positive correlation with only one anatomical characteristic of the differentiation root region (epidermis thickness) and three of the division root region (parenchymatic cell area, protoderm thickness and transverse area); while the PC1 has aon egative correlation with theon umber of parenchymatic cells of both the differentiation and cell division regions. To all appearances, the CP1 was related to the entire process of mitosis, elongation and maturation occurring in the first centimeter of the root tip. Regarding the PC2, the contrary occurred, as it had a positive correlation with the diameter of the parenchymatic vessels and transverse area in both of the root regions.

When the PC1 was plotted against the PC2 and PC3 and the third against the PC2, a small overlap was observed between the wild and domesticated common bean (Figure not shown); however, the triplot in Figure 6 clearly demonstrates the domesticated common bean and the wild accession to be independent biological units. Under the study conditions, the anatomical root characteristics that promoted independence related mainly to root growth (transversal area and cells quantity), water conduction and permeability (epidermis and xylem) in PC1. It is important to remember that the upper side of the meristem begins to elongate because of the absorption of large amounts of water into cell vacuoles. As cells stretch, they increase in length up to four times their original size, as this is the region where growth converts to length. Elongation provides forcé to push the root tip through soil (Ma and Peterson, 2003). The PC2 enhanced the common bean's separation. This PC was composed mainly of two characteristics of the root differentiation region (diameter of the parenchymatic vessels and the transverse area of both root regions). In these root regions cells mature and start changing their structure and function. Finally, PC3 had a high positive correlation (0.8522) with theon umber of xylem vessels in the root differentiation region. This is interpreted as a highly important characteristic for root reaction to low substrate ψW and independent of the rest. Among the 10 anatomical characteristics, only thickness of the xylem wall had a low relative contribution to the first three PC, andon one of them made a high contribution for structuring more than one PC (Table 2). Anatomical modifications areon eeded in some plant tissues to continue physiological processes under stressful conditions. This is the case of xylem (diameter andon umber of vessels), which is the upward transportation system of water and dissolvedon utrients.

The triplot in Figure 6 shows that it is possible to distinguish between domesticated and wild beans using anatomical root characteristics. This PC analysis shows clear differences between common beans, growing under low ψW (between -0.65 to -2.35 MPa) or even at optimal substrate ψW of -0.03 MPa. Furthermore, significant differences are also evident in the cell division and differentiation regions, ensuring a contrasting reaction at an anatomical level in the root to substrate ψW that occurred with domestication, as opposed to the wild common bean's adaptation to a fluctuating environment that includes erratic precipitation and competition for water withon eighboring plants. Most variance at the root cell division and differentiation regions was captured in the first 3PC's (PC1: 45.91 %, PC2: 17.38 % and PC3: 11.01 %), totaling 74.30 % of the observed variance. In these seedling roots it was possible to differentiate specialized tissues (e.g. epidermis, endodermis), histological root region (cell division region and differentiation region), and the reaction of common bean seedlings to substrate ψW and that of wild and domesticated common bean to ψW (Figure 6).

The results suggest that during the domestication process of the common bean a significant slimming of root protoderm took place, as well as an increase in theon umber and thickness of xylem vessels. It also seems that during domestication some root reactions to low substrate ψW have changed. Our results also indicate that protoxylem vessels in wild common bean roots are significantly thinner than those in domesticated common beans, this could be one of the most relevant characteristics that allows tolerance to low ψW, as smaller vessel diameter could favor the tolerance of the wild common bean to water deficit, due to the axial resistance to water flux resistance.


Substrate ψW between -0.65 and -2.35 MPa modified (epidermis and protoderm thickness), with different intensity (parenchymatic cell area,on umber of cortex cells and thickness of xylem wall), or different trends (number and diameter of xylem vessels and transverse root area) the anatomical root characteristics in the domesticated common bean seedlings compared to wild ones. A key finding was that the diameter of xylem vessels is decreased in the domesticated bean roots compared to those of the wild type, in which diameter was the same, from -0.03 to -2.5 MPa. This means that wild beans doon ot reduce their growing root capacity at low ψW. In general, the strongest reaction of domesticated common bean roots was observed at ψW of -2.35 MPa compared with the wild common bean. Multivariate PC analysis of anatomical root characteristics and their modifications in both differentiation and cell division regions as a reaction to low substrate ψW demonstrated that the wild common bean reacted quite differently from the domesticated one to low substrate ψW. This suggests that root anatomical changes during domesticationon egatively modified the capacity of the common bean to respond to drought stress.


We are grateful to Biol. Baruch Arroyo P. for the critical reading of the manuscript and English revision.



ARROYO-PEÑA B, PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, SÁNCHEZ-URDANETA AB (2005) Efecto del potencial de agua en la germinación de semillas de frijol (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) silvestre y domesticado. SABER, Revista Multidisciplinaria del Consejo de Investigación. Suplemento Vol. 17: 237-239.

DA SILVA S, CASTRO EM, SOARES AM (2003) Effects of different water regimes on the anatomical characteristics of roots of grasses promising for revegetation of areas surrounding hydroelectric reservoirs. Cienc Agrotec Lavras 27: 393-397

FACETTE MR, MCCULLY ME, CANNY MJ (1999) Response of maize roots to drying-limits of viability. Plant Cell Environ 22: 1559-1568.

GARCÍA-NAVA R, PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, RUÍZ PLM, TREJO LC (1999) Effect of synthetic ABA in root growth of domesticated and wild Phaseolus vulgaris L. Ann Rep Bean Improv Cooperative 42:85-86.

HOSE E, CLARKSON DT, STEUDLE E, SCHREIBER L, HARTUNG W (2001) The exodermis: a variable apoplastic barrier. J Exp Bot 52: 2245-2264

INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANCE (2007a) Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability: contribution of working group II to the fourth assessment report of the IPCC. http//

INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANCE (2007b) Climate Change Mitigation: contribution of working group III to the fourth assessment report of the IPCC.

LUX A, LUXOVA M, ABE J, MORITA S (2004) Root cortex: structural and functional variability and responses to environmental stress. Root Res 13: 117-131.

MA F, PETERSON CA (2003) Current insights into the development and chemistry of the endodermis and of roots. Can J Bot 81: 405-421.

NICOTRA AB, BABICKA N , WESTOBY N (2002) Seedling root anatomy and morphology: an examination of ecological differentiation with rainfall using phylogenetically independent contrasts. Oecologia 130:136-145

NORTH BG, PETERSON CA (2005) Water flow in roots: structural and regulatory features. In: Vascular Transport in Plants, eds. N.M. Holbrook and M.A. Zwieniecki. Publ. Elsevier Academic Press, New York. pp. 131-156.

PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, GARCÍA N R, AGUIRRE RJR, TREJO LC (2002) High temperature breaks dormancy and increases hypocotyl-root growth of wild common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Seed Sc Tech 30: 231-248.

PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, SÁNCHEZ-URDANETA AB, TREJO C, AGUIRRE RJR, CÁRDENAS E (2005) Root anatomy of drought sensitive and tolerant maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings under different water potentials. Cereal Res Comm 33: 705-712.

PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, SÁNCHEZ-URDANETA AB (2009) Effects of substrate water potential in root growth of Agave salmiana Otto ex Salm-Dyck seedlings. Biol Res 42: 239-248.

SALEEM M, LAMKEMEYER T, SCHÜTZENMEISTER, MADLUNG J, SAKAI H, PIEPHO HP, NORDHEIM A, HOCHHOLDINGE F (2010) Specification of cortical parenchyma and stele of maize primary roots by asymmetric levels of auxin, cytokinin, and cytokinin-regulated proteins. Plant Physiol 152: 4-18.

SÁNCHEZ-URDANETA AB, PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, TREJO C, AGUIRRE RJR, CÁRDENAS SE, GALICIA JA (2003) Permeabilidad de las membranas radicales de plántulas de frijol (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) silvestre y domesticado bajo deficit de humedad. Interciencia 28: 597-603.

SANCHEZ-URDANETA AB, PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, AGUIRRE RJR, TREJO LC, CÁRDENAS-SORIANO E, GALICIA JAB (2004a) Crecimiento de la raíz de plántulas de frijol (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) silvestre y domesticado con deficit de humedad. Acta Científica Potosina 16: 18-42

SÁNCHEZ-URDANETA AB, PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, AGUIRRE RJR, TREJO LC, CÁRDENAS-SORIANO E (2004b) Efectos del potencial de agua en el crecimiento radical de plántulas de Agave salmiana Otto Ex Salm-Dyck. Interciencia 29: 626-631.

SÁNCHEZ-URDANETA AB, PEÑA-VALDIVIA CB, TREJO LC, AGUIRRE RJR, CÁRDENAS SE (2005) Root growth and proline content in drought sensitive and tolerant maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings under different water potentials. Cereal Res Comm 33:697-704.

SAS. 1999-2000. SAS user's guide: Statistics. Version 8.1 Edition. SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC. USA. 1290 p.

SHAO H-B, CHU L-Y, JALEEL CA, ZHAO C-X (2008) Water-deficit stress-induced anatomical changes in higher plants. C R Biologies 33: 215-225

TERAN, H.; SINGH, S.P. 2002. Comparison of sources and lines selected for drought resistance in common bean. Crop Sci. 42: 64-70

URREA CA, YONTS CD, LYON DJ, KOEHLER AE (2009) Selection for drought tolerance in dry bean derived from the Mesoamerican gene pool in westernon ebraska. Crop Sci 49: 2005-2010.

WILCOX D, DOVE B, MCDAVID D, GREER D (2002) Image Tool for Windows. Version 3.0. The University of Texas Health ScienceCenter. San Antonio, Texas.


Received: September 9, 2009. In revised form: Agust 13, 2010. Accepted: September 1, 2010.

* Corresponding Author: Cecilia B. Peña-Valdivia, Botánica, Colegio de Postgraduados. Km 35.5 Carretera Mexico-Texcoco, Montecillo, Mexico. 56230. E-mail: and

Creative Commons License Todo el contenido de esta revista, excepto dónde está identificado, está bajo una Licencia Creative Commons