versión On-line ISSN 0717-9502
Int. J. Morphol. v.26 n.4 Temuco dic. 2008
Int. J. Morphol., 26(4):981-987, 2008.
The Mental Foramen Position in Dentate and Edentulous Brazilian's Mandible
Posición del Foramen Mental en Mandíbulas de Brasileños Dentados Desdentados
*Maise Mendonca Amorim; *Felippe Bevilacqua Prado; *Cynthia Bicalho Borini; **Telmo Oliveira Bittar; ***Maria Cristina Volpato; ***Francisco Carlos Groppo & ****Paulo Henrique Ferreira Caria
* DDS, MSc. Gradúate student, Department of Morphology, Anatomy Área, State University of Campiñas, Brasil.
** DDS, MSc - Gradúate student, Department of Community Health, State University of Campiñas, Brasil.
*** DDS, PhD - Chairman, Department of Physiological Sciences, State University of Campiñas, Brasil.
**** DDS, PhD - Associate Professor, Department of Morphology, Anatomy Área, State University of Campiñas, Brasil.
SUMMARY: The mental foramen has been reported to vary in position in different ethnic groups. Repeated failures during injections and operative procedures involving the mental foramen suggest the presence of local differences in a given population. The aim of the present study was to determine the position of mental foramen (MF) in a sample of one hundred seventy Brazilian adult dry mandible, being 79 edentulous and 91 dentate. The assessment was made, having as it referential, the base of the mandible (BM) and the mandibular symphisis (MS), whereby the comparisons were carried out considering genders, the mandible side (left or right), and dentition (dentate or edentulous). The statistical analysis was performed using multifatorial ANO VA (alpha=5%). It was found the male mandibles presented higher valúes of MF-MS than the female ones and the dentate presented higher valúes when compared to edentulous ones (p<0.0001). No difference was observed between left and right sides (p=0.2990), as well, as concerning to gender (p=0.152). The most frequent position of MF was in the long axes of the second premolar for male (p<0.0001) and female (p=0.0004). No statistical difference (p>0.05) was found between right and left sides comparing male to female. It was concluded the position of the mental foramen is mainly altered in edentulous subjects as it is consider a symmetric structure in Brazilian population and its most common position is in the long axes of the secondpremolar.
KEY WORDS: Mandibles; Mental Foramen.
RESUMEN: El foramen mental ha sido reportado variablemente en diferentes posiciones, según los grupos étnicos. Repetidos errores durante el procedimiento anestésico, que involucran al foramen mental, sugieren la presencia de diferencias locales en una determinada población. El objetivo del presente estudio fue determinar la posición del foramen mental (MF) en una muestra de 170 mandíbulas secas de la población brasileña, siendo 79 desdentadas y 91 dentadas. La evaluación fue hecha teniendo como referencia la base de la mandíbula (BM) y la sínfisis mandibular (MS). La comparación fue dada y llevada por géneros, según el lado de la mandíbula (izquierdo o derecho) y la dentición (dentada o desdentada). El análisis estadístico fue realizado usando el test multifactorial ANOVA (alpha 5%). Mandíbulas masculinas presentaron valores mayores que el grupo femenino y las mandíbulas dentadas presentaron valores superiores, cuando fueron comparadas con las mandíbulas desdentadas (p<0.0001). Ninguna diferencia fue observada entre los lados derecho e izquierdo (p=0.2990), como tampoco para los géneros masculino y femenino (p=0.152). La posición más frecuente de MF para las mandíbulas masculinas fue a lo largo del eje del segundo premolar (p<0.0001), así como para las mandíbulas femeninas (p=0.0004). No fueron encontradas diferencias estadísticamente significativas (p>0.05) entre los lados derecho e izquierdo, comparando mandíbulas masculinas y femeninas. Se concluye que la posición del foramen mental es principalmente alterada en sujetos desdentados, es considerada una estructura simétrica en la población brasilera y más comúnmente localizado a lo largo del eje del segundo premolar.
PALABRAS CLAVE: Mandíbulas; Foramen Mental.
The orientation and position of the mental foramen is important to performing anesthetic block prior to clinical procedures in lower-anterior teeth and also to preserve the integrity of the mental nerve trunk in surgical interventions (Julián et al, 1998; Cutright et al., 2003; Mwaniki & Hassanali, 1992). The mental nerve injury can cause transitory or permanent sensitive, thermal and tactile changes (Phillips et al., 1990; Wismeijer et al, 1997).
The location of the mental foramen has been studied by means of direct measurement on dry mandibles or by using radiographs of dry mandibles or patients (Phillips et al, 1990; Phillips et al., 1992b; Agthong et al., 2005; Apinhasmit et al., 2006; Captier et al., 2006.
A number of studies have shown difference in the position of the mental foramen in relation to the second premolar according to the ethnic group studied. The literature shows studies conducted on Asians (Chung et al., 1995; Igbigbi & Lebona, 2005), Africans (Mbajiorgu et al., 1998; Olasoji et al., 2004; Souaga et al., 2004) and Caucasians (Cutright et al, 2003).
The Brazilian population shows high degree of miscegenation (IBGE, Brazil, 2000) and the literature on the location of the mental foramen in this population is very scarce (de Freitas et al, 1975; de Freitas et al., 1976) henee does not present any statistical analysis.
The development of implant techniques increased the interest in the mandible anatomy, specially the MF localization. Despite this interest a small number of papers has been published on the position of mental foramen in edentulous subjects (Soikkonen et al., 1995; Güler et al., 2005; Captier et al.).
The aim of this paper was to evalúate the position of the mental foramen in dentate and edentulous Brazilian subjects attempting to spot a light to surgical interventions and anesthetic block procedures.
MATERIAL AND METHOD
One hundred and seventy human Brazilian dry mandibles (91 dentate and 79 edentulous) were obtained from the collection of Piracicaba Dental School and Institute of Biology, State University of Campiñas - UNICAMP, Brazil. The dentate mandibles presented a mean of at least 14 erupted teeth whereas the edentulous present any. Hundred eighteen mandibles were from male gender and 52 from female. All of them have shown any osseous or dental abnormalities.
This study was performed of directly measures and observations, over dry mandibles as it is described:
Position of the mental foramen (MF)to the mandibular symphisis (MS) and the base of the mandible (BM) as shown in Fig. 1.
Mandibles were placed on a standard basal plañe searching the maximous contact surface when a vertical pressure was applied to the región of the second molars. The distance between the center of mental foramen and the mandibular symphisis (midline of the mandible) was then measured. This measure was performed on a plañe parallel to the standard basal plañe.
The distance between the mental foramen center to the base of the mandible was measured on a vertical straight Une perpendicular to the standard basal plañe passing on the center of the mental foramen.
The measurements were performed with a digital pachymeter of 0.01 mm accuracy (Mitutoyo, Japan), by one investigator. Three measurements were conducted with one week interval and submitted to intraclass coefficient (ICC) analysis to assess the measurement replicability. Multifactorial ANOVA was performed to analyze the influence of the variables (gender, side and dental state) on the measurements. The significance level adopted was 5%.
The orientation and position of the mental foramen was visually inspected. According to its orientation it was classified as posterior-superior, superior and posterior. The results were submitted to Kruskal-Wallis test with 5% significance level.
The location of the mental foramen in relation to the mandibular teeth was assessed in the dentate mandible and classified in one of the following positions (Tebo & Telford, 1950): position 1- mesial to the first premolar; position 2- in line with the long axes of the first premolar; position 3- between the first and second premolar; position 4- in line with the long axes of the second premolar; position 5- between the second premolar and the first molar; position 6- at the mesial half of the first molar. The results were submitted to Qui-square test adopting 5% significance level.
The valúes obtained for the ICC were higher than 0.98; therefore the replicability was considered excellent.
Position of the mental foramen (MF) to the mandibular symphisis (MS) and base of the mandible (BM)
Table I shows the results of the measurements from mental foramen to the mandibular symphisis (MF-MS) and from the mental foramen to the base of the mandible (MF-BM), according to the side, gender and dental stat .
Data analysis showed that gender (p<0.0001) and dental status (p<0.0001) significantly affected the measure MF-MS; the male mandibles presented higher valúes than the female ones and the dentate presented higher valúes when compared to the edentulous mandibles. No difference was observed between left and right sides (p=0.2990).Considering the FM-BM measurement, the dentate mandibles presented higher valúes (p<0.0001) than the edentulous ones. No differences were observed in relation to the gender (p=0.1520) and side (p=0.4420).
Fig. 2 shows the graphical representation of the variation of mental foramen according to the measures performed.
Orientation of the mental foramen (MF) and position in relation to the teeth.
Table II shows the results for orientation of the mental foramen. No differences (p=0.9682) were observed in relation to the gender, dental status, and side.
The position of the mental foramen in relation to the mandibular teeth is shown in Table III. The most frequent position of the mental foramen was in line with the long axes of the second premolar for male (p<0.0001) and female (p=0.0004). No difference (p>0.05) was found between sides for both, male and female.
Finally, no accessory or múltiple foramens were observed in this study.
The location of the mental foramen is an important factor when considering the mental and incisive anesthetic block and surgeries in the outer premolar mandibular región. The present study shows, for the Brazilian population, the location in line with the long axes of the second premolar as the most common position of the mental foramen, followed by the position between the first premolars. These results, in consistence with others (Freitas et al., 1975; Phillips et al.; Apinhasmit et al.; Mwaniki & Hassanali 1992; Ari et al, 2005; Oguz & Bozkir, 2002 and Cutright et al, 2003) show this is the most common finding in the majority of the ethnic groups. A few number of researches has shown these two locations in inverse order as the most common positions for the mental foramen (Olasoji et al.) or with similar percentages of frequency for Saudis, for white Americans and for Jordanians claimed by others.
As observed previously by Apinhasmit et al. and now in the present study this parameter is not influenced by gender.
Another parameter that seems to show little variance among races is the orientation of exit of the mental foramen. As shown by others, such as Apinhasmit in Thais, Mwaniki & Hassanali in Kenian Africans, Igbigbi & Lebona in Malawian, and Phillips in mandibles with unknown race, the postero-superior direction is the most common orientation of exit of the mental foramen.
Concerning the measurements, the FM-BI measures of the dentate mandibles studied are in the same range observed by other studies (Phillips et al.; Oguz et al; Agthong et al.; Apinhasmit et al). Contrary to the findings of Agthong et al., dentate mandible showed bigger FM-BI measure than edentulous mandibles. This difference can be related to the high variabihty of the results and small number of edentulous mandibles (2) evaluated by these authors. According to the findings of Güler et al. no differences werefound among genders in the FM-BI measure.
Considering the means and the respective standard deviations for MF-MS measures in dentate mandibles, the results of the present study were similar to that observed for black Africans, Chinese and Thai subjects (Souaga et al. and Apinhasmit et al.) and bigger than that related for white British, Korean, and black and white Americans (Chung et al. and Cutright et al). In the present study, male mandibles presented bigger MF-MS measures than female ones, similar to the result observed previously by Apinhasmit et al., however, this outcome was not observed by Chung et al. and Cutright et al.
The difference between genders was also found in the edentulous mandibles for the MF-MS measure, which are in agreement with that of Güler et al., but with less individual variabihty.
As observed for the FM-BI measures, the dentate mandibles showed bigger MF-MS measures, which can be related to the mechanic forces of mastication and the consequent osseous deposition response for consolidation of the mandibular symphisis región, as the factors associated to the alveolar osseous growth that follows the anterior teeth eruption (Hylander, 1984; Kaifu, 1997). Therefore, the atrophic processes that took part in the edentulous mandibles with alveolar bone resorption may be responsible for the lower measures observed in these specimens.
the measures as shown by the standard deviation in some studies (Apinhasmit et al. and Chung et al). This variability could be due to individual variability or to the instrument of measurement. Although Brazilian population presents a high degree of miscegenation (IBGE, 2000), little variability was found among measurement sample.
Concerning the ethnic factor, the Brazilian population sample studied presents results more similar to Africans and Chinese, with bigger measures than other ethnic groups.
In addition, muscle forces, facial biotype, teeth size, shape and size of neurocranium, diet habits, the head position, environmental influences, and socioeconomic factors, along with ethnic characteristics and racial miscegenation could also change the mastication function and mandibular morphology (Bogin & Rios 2003; Prado & Caria 2007).
The differences observed among studies may be related to different methodology, such as measurements on skull photographs (Chung et al.) or different skull marks - center versus anterior or inferior border of the mental foramen or abscense of skull marks information (Cutright).
Another important factor is the great variability of Although the inferior third of face is related as the most asymmetric portion of the skull (Türp et al, 1998; Melnik, 1992), this statement wasnot observed in the parameters related to the mental foramen analyzed in the present study, which corrobórate the findings of Captier et al. for dentate and edentulous subjects.
In conclusión the position of the mental foramen is altered in edentulous when compared with dentate subjects. Mental foramen is a symmetric structure in Brazilian population being most commonly located in the long axes of the second premolar as it was previously described by others elsewhere. Thus, our findings are in consistence with previous studies described before showing little variations for Brazialian etnhology.
Agthong, S.; Huanmanop, T. & Chentane, V. Anatomical Variations of the Supraorbital, Infraorbital, and Mental Foramina Related to Gender and Side. J. Oral Maxillo fac. Surg., 63:800-4, 2005. [ Links ]
Apinhasmit, W.; Chompoopong, S.; Methathrathip, D.; Sansuk, R. & Phetphunphiphat W. Supraorbital Noten/ Foramen, Infraorbital Foramen and Mental Foramen in Thais: anthropometric measurements and surgical relevance J. Med. Assoc. Thai., 89(5):675-82, 2006. [ Links ]
Ari, I.; Kafa, I.M.; Basar, Z. & Kurt, M.A. The localization and anthropometry of mental foramen on late Byzantine mandibles. Coll. Antropol, 29(1):233-6, 2005. [ Links ]
Bogin, B. & Ríos, L. Rapid morphological change in living humans; implications for modern human origins. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. A. Molí Integr. Physiol., 136(1): 71-84, 2003. [ Links ]
Captier, G.; Lethuilier, J.; Oussaid, M.; Cánovas, F. & Bonnel, F. Neural symmetry and functional asymmetry of the mandible. Surg. Radiol. Anal, 25:379-86,1976. [ Links ]
Chung, M.S.; Kim, H.J.; Kang, H.S. et al: Locational relationship of the supraorbital notch or foramen and infraorbital and mental foramina in Koreans. Acta Anat. (Basel) 154:162, 1995. [ Links ]
Cutright, B.; Quillopa, N. & Schubert, W. An Anthropometric Analysis of the Key Foramina for Maxillofacial Surgery J.Oral Maxillofac. Surg., 67:354-7, 2003. [ Links ]
de Freitas, V.; Madeira, M.C.; Zorzetto, N.L.; Pinto, C.T. & Piffer, C.R. Contribuicao para o estudo da localizacao e das variacoes do forame mental em mandíbulas humanas. Rev. bras odont., 32(194):l56-60,1975. [ Links ]
de Freitas, V.; Madeira, M.C.; Pinto, C.T. & Zorzetto, N. L. Direction of the mental canal in human mandibles. Aust. Dent. J., 21(4):338-40, 1976. [ Links ]
Güler, A. U.; Sumer, M.; Sumer R & Bicer I. The evaluation of vertical heights of maxillary and mandibular bones and the location of anatomic landmarks in panoramic radiographs of edentulous patients for implant dentistry. J. of Oral Rehabilitation, 32:741-6, 2005. [ Links ]
Hylander, W.L. Stress and strain in the mandibular symphysis of primates: a test of competing hypotheses. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol, 64(1):1-46, 1984. [ Links ]
Igbigbi, P S. & Lebona, S. The position and dimensions of the mental foramen in adult Malawian mandibles. West Afr. J. Med, 24(3):U4-9, 2005. [ Links ]
Julián, R. D. & Chapel Hill, N. C. Position of the mental foramen in a North American, white population. Oral Surg. Oral Med. OralPathol. Oral Radiol. Endod., 85: 457-60, 1998. [ Links ]
Kaifu, Y. Changes in mandibular morphology from the Yomon to modern periods in eastern Japan. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol, 104(2): 227-43, 1997. [ Links ]
Kordatzis, K.; Wright, P S. & Meijer, H. J. Posterior mandibular residual ridge resorption in patients with conventional dentures and implant overdentures. Int. J. Oral Maxillo fac. Implaras, 8(3):441-52, 2003. [ Links ]
Machida, N.; Yamada, K.; Takata, Y. & Yamada, Y. Relationship between facial asymmetry and masseter reflex activity. J. Oral Maxillofac. Surg., 67:298-303, 2003. [ Links ]
Mbajiorgu, E. F; Mawera, G.; Ásala, S.A. & Zivanovic, S. Position of the mental foramen in adult black Zimbabwean mandibles: A clinical anatomical study. Cent. Afr. J. Med., 44(2):24-30, 1998. [ Links ]
Melnik, A. K. A cephalometric study of mandibular asymmetry in a longitudinally followed sample of growing children. Am. J. Orthod. Dentofacial Orthop., 101:355-66, 1992. [ Links ]
Mwaniki, D. L. & Hassanali, J. The position of mandibular and mental foramina in Kenyan African mandibles. East AfricanMed. J., 69:210-3, 1992. [ Links ]
Al Jasser, N. M. & Nwoku, A. L. Radiographic study of the mental foramen in a selected Saudi population. Dentomaxillofacial Radiólogy., 27:341-3,1998. [ Links ]
Oguz, O. & Bozkir, M.G. Evaluation of location of mandibular and mental foramina in dry, young, adult human male, dentulous mandibles. West Indian Med. J., 51 (1): 14-6, 2002. [ Links ]
Olasoji, H.O.; Tahir, A.; Ekanem, A.U. & Abubakar, A.A. Radiographic and anatomic locations of mental foramen in northern Nigerian adults. Niger Postgrad. Med. J., 11(3):230-3, 2004. [ Links ]
Phillips, J. L.; Weller, N. & Klild, J. C. The Mental Foramen: Part I. Size, Orientation, and Positional Relationship to the Mandibular Second Premolar. J. of Endodontics, 16(5):221-23,1990. [ Links ]
Pickering, R. B. & Bachman, D.C. The Use of Forensic Anthropology. Boca Ratón, FL, CRC Press, 1997, pp 84. [ Links ]
Polland, K.E.; Munro, S.; Reford, G.; Lockhart, A, Logan G, Brocklebank L, McDonald SW. The mandibular canal of the edentulous jaw. Clin Anat. 2001 Nov;14(6):445-52. [ Links ]
Prado, F. B & Caria, P.H.F. Comparaciones morfológicas entre las mandíbulas de brasileños y de poblaciones de cuatro otros continentes. Int. J. Morphol, 25(2):323-7, 2007. [ Links ]
Rosas, A. Occurrence of neanderthal features in mandibles from the Atapuerca-SH site. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol, 114(1):14-91, 2001. [ Links ]
Soikkonen, K.; Wolf, J.; Ainamo, A. & Qiufei, X. Changes in the position of the mental foramen as a result of alveolar atrophy. J.of Oral Rehabilitation, 22:831-3, 1995. [ Links ]
Souaga, K.; Adou, A. & Angoh, Y. Topographical and morphological study of the mandibular foramen in black Africans from the Ivory Coast. Odontostomatol. Trop., 27(105):11-21,2004. [ Links ]
Stefan, V. H. & Trinkaus, E.. Discrete trait and dental morphometric affinities of the Tabun 2 mandible. J. Hum. Evol, 34:443-68, 1998a. [ Links ]
Stefan, V. H. & Trinkaus, E. La Quina 9 and Neandertal mandibular variability. Bull. Mem. Soc. Anthropol. París., 7(9:293-324, 1998b. [ Links ]
Tebo, T G & Telford, I.B. An analysis of the variations in position of the mental foramen. Anat. Rec, 107:61-6, 1960. [ Links ]
Türp, J. C; Alt, K.W.; Vach, W. & Harbich, K. Mandibular condyles and rami are asymmetric structures. Cranio, 16(1):51-6, 1998. [ Links ]
Wismeijer, D.; Van Waas, M.A.; Vermeeren, J. I. & Kalk, W. Patients perception of sensory disturbances of the mental nerve before and after implant surgery: a prospective study of 110 patients. Br. J. Oral Maxillo fac. Surg., 35:254-9,1997. [ Links ]
Correspondence to: Maise Mendonga Amorim
Faculdade de Odontología de Piracicaba - FOP/UNICAMP, AV. Limeira, 901 - Bairro Areião. Cep: 13414-903 Piracicaba - SP. BRASIL. Tel: (55) (19) 3412-5330.
Received: 08-04-2008, Accepted: 14-09-2008.