versión On-line ISSN 0717-7356
Chungará (Arica) vol.43 no.1 Arica jun. 2011
Volumen 43, N° 1, 2011. Páginas 135-146
Chungara, Revista de Antropología Chilena
NONSPECIFIC INFECTIOUS DISEASES IN PREHISTORIC SAN PEDRO DE ATACAMA, NORTHERN CHILE
ENFERMEDADES INFECCIOSAS NO-ESPECÍFICAS EN POBLACIONES PREHISTÓRICAS DE SAN PEDRO DE ATACAMA, NORTE DE CHILE
Pedro José Tótora da-Gloria1, Walter Alves Neves2, Maria Antonietta Costa Junqueira3, and Rafael Bartolomucci4
1 Department of Anthropology, The Ohio State University, 4034 Smith Laboratory 174 W. 18th Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA. email@example.com
2Laboratório de Estudos Evolutivos Humanos, Instituto de Genética e Biologia Evolutiva, Universidade de São Paulo, Brasil. firstname.lastname@example.org
3 Instituto de Investigaciones Arqueológicas y Museo, Universidad Católica del Norte. San Pedro de Atacama, Chile. email@example.com
4 Museu de Arqueologia e Etnologia, Universidade de São Paulo, Brasil. firstname.lastname@example.org
The region of San Pedro de Atacama, Northern Chile, has undergone several cultural and social changes after humans settled in Atacama Desert around 500 BC. The Atacameño people experienced the highest degree of social and cultural changes between 400 and 900 AD when they were assimilated into the Tiwanaku trade and political web that influenced most of the Central-Southern Andes. Under the influence of Tiwanaku, San Pedro de Atacama experienced its greatest economic development. Prior analyses of local human skeletal remains have shown a significant increase in the stature of the local population during the same period. In this paper, we investigate the impact of the Tiwanaku influence on the local epidemiological profile using the incidence of periostitis and osteomyelitis as indicators of biological stress. Surprisingly, the best epidemiological condition occurred during the final phase of influence of Tiwanaku (910-960 AD), and not during the apex influence (480-920 AD), as expected by the archaeological context. We suggest that population growth and aggregation may have counteracted the benefits of improved nutrition during the peak Tiwanaku influence. A severe drought occurred between 1,100 and 1,400 AD in Northern Chile. This could also explain the marked increase of bone infections in the post-Tiwanaku period (920-1,240 AD).
Key words: Atacama Desert, bioarchaeology, biological quality of life, Tiwanaku, epidemiology.
La región de San Pedro de Atacama, Norte de Chile, experimentó varios cambios culturales y sociales desde los primeros asentamientos humanos alrededor de los 500 a.c., aunque los más altos grados de cambio los sufrieron los atacameños entre 400 y 900 d.C., cuando fueron establecidas conexiones con la red cultural y de intercambio de Tiwanaku, cultura ésta que ejerció influencia sobre la mayor parte de los andes centro-sur. Bajo esta influencia, San Pedro de Atacama tuvo su mayor desarrollo económico. Análisis anteriores de restos esqueletales humanos han mostrado un significativo aumento en la estatura de la población local durante el mismo período. En este trabajo investigamos el impacto de la influencia Tiwanaku en el perfil epidemiológico local, usando la incidencia de periostitis y de osteomielitis como indicadores de estrés biológico. La mejor situación epidemiológica ocurrió durante el final de la fase de influencia de Tiwanaku (910-960 d.C.) y no durante el ápice de esta influencia (480-920 d.C.), como sería de esperar por el contexto arqueológico. Sugerimos que el crecimiento poblacional y la consecuente congregación pudo haber contrarrestado los beneficios de una mejor nutrición durante el auge de la influencia altiplánica. Una severa sequía ocurrió entre 1.100 y 1.400 d.C. en el norte de chile, lo que podría explicar el marcado aumento de las infecciones óseas en el período post-Tiwanaku (920-1.240 d.C.).
Palabras claves: desierto de atacama, bioarqueología, calidad de vida biológica, Tiwanaku, epidemiología.
San Pedro de Atacama is located in the Atacama Desert, Northern Chile (Figure 1), one of the most arid regions of the planet. Permanent settlement in the small oasis within the desert was possible only after the development of agriculture and camelid husbandry in the Andes (Llagostera 1996). Archaeological data tell us that the first farmers in the Oasis of Atacama were settled around 500 BC using maize as their main staple (Núñez 1992). The Atacameño culture lasted until the arrival of the Spaniards in the region in the 16th century. During the period that sepa rates the genesis of the Atacameño culture and its collapse subsequent to European arrival, the local population experienced several changes (Llagostera and Costa 1984).
One of the most dramatic of these changes occurred between 400 and 900 AD, triggered by the rise (and expansion) of Tiwanaku located in the Titicaca valley, in the Bolivian altiplano (Janusek 2002; Kolata 1993). Tiwanaku culture had a profound impact on various surrounding populations, including San Pedro de Atacama in Northern Chile (Bermann 1997; Browman 1980; Kolata 1993; Neves et al. 1996; Stanish and Steadman 1994; Torres-Rouff 2008). During the peak of Tiwanaku influence in the region, there is archaeological evidence for a more elaborate material culture (Le Paige 1965; Llagostera et al. 1988; Rodman 1992) and increases in social complexity and stratification (Llagostera 1996; Llagostera 2004). San Pedro de Atacama appears to have received a strong religious and economic influence, although low population input from Tiwanaku has been detected (Knudson 2008). Further, all the oases were occupied during this period, showing an increase in the density of the settlements (Llagostera and Costa 1999).
After the collapse of the Tiwanaku capital around 900 AD and the rupture of its sociopolitical and commercial network, the Atacama population experienced an impoverishment of the material culture associated with an increase in social tension (Llagostera 2004). A regional drought is pointed out as a significant factor in the social changes occurred in the central-southern Andes (Binford et al. 1997; Ortloff and Kolata 1993).
Since 1986, two of us (WAN and MAC) have been assessing the impact of Tiwanaku influence on the local population of San Pedro de Atacama. Human skeletal remains uncovered from three burial sites of the region have been intensively analyzed for this purpose. These sites cover the main periods of the local prehistory (Costa 1988; Costa and Neves 1990; Neves et al. 1996). It has been already demonstrated (Neves and Costa 1998) that at least one widely accepted osteological marker of quality of life –adult stature (Steckel 1995)– indicates an improvement in the nutritional conditions during the Tiwanaku period compared with the situation before and after the altiplanic influence. This picture was corroborated more recently (Costa et al. 2004) by the assessment of caries and tooth wear in the same skeletons. These markers also suggest a diet richer in animal protein during the influence of Tiwanaku in San Pedro (Neves et al. 2000).
In this paper, we assess the impact of Tiwanaku on the quality of life in Atacama, examining the incidence and distribution of nonspecific infectious disease in the local population. We work with the hypothesis that the influence of Tiwanaku improved the quality of life of Atacameño people. This hypothesis is supported by both the degree of sophistication of the local material culture during the Tiwanaku influence and the high stature of the population during this same period. In short, we expect that the infections, opposite to stature, will be lower during the Tiwanaku apex.
Material and Methods
The skeletal material used in this work comprises 156 adults and 88 subadults (less than 19 years) skeletons uncovered from the sites of Solcor-3, Quitor-6 and Coyo-3 (Table 1 and Figure 2). These three sites are located in the oasis of San Pedro de Atacama and were excavated during the last 25 years (Llagostera and Costa 1999). They range in time from 250 to 1240 AD. Solcor-3 has two components: a pre-Tiwanaku section (250 to 480 AD) and one representing the period under the apex influence of Tiwanaku (480 to 920 AD). Details about this site can be found in Llagostera et al. (1988). Coyo-3 represents the period of final influence of Tiwanaku (Costa and Llagostera 1994). In fact, Coyo-3 is dated from 910 to 960, overlapping with the previous and later periods (Table 1). In that sense, Coyo represents exactly the transition between apex and post Tiwanaku influence in San Pedro de Atacama. Quitor-6 represents the post-Tiwanaku period (pre-Inca); this site is dated from 920 to 1240 AD. Details about Quitor-6 can be found in Costa (1988). This burial site coincides with the peak of a drought in the Central Andes (Berenguer 2000; Binford et al. 1997).
Figure 2. Detailed map of the Atacama Salar showing the three sites analyzed (adapted from Costa et al. 2004).
Detalle del mapa del salar de atacama mostrando los tres sitios analizados (adaptado de costa et al. 2004).
All skeletons were screened for visible marks of infectious disease in the major anatomical parts of the body (cranium, ribs, sternum, shoulder girdle, arms, hands, pelvis, legs and feet) by two of the authors (WAN and MAC). Ortner and Putschar (1981) were used as the standard of reference in the osteological analysis. In the case of the skull, alveolar infections (abscesses) were not included here. No attempt was made to identify the specific etiology of the infections or to associate specific pathogens to specific kinds of lesions. The infections were classified in two main groups: periostitis and osteomyelitis. These terms are used here as general descriptive categories (Ortner and Putschar 1981).
Periostitis was defined as any trace of infection restricted to the surface of the bone, while osteomyelitis was defined as any trace of infection which invaded the medullar cavity (Birkett 1983; Kelley 1989; Ortner and Putschar 1981). In the first case, visual inspection focused on any sign of periosteal reaction and inflammation. These included the formation of sclerotic bone and thickening of the periosteal layer not associated with callus formation derived from trauma. In the case of osteomyelitis, visual inspection focused on signs of sequestra and of cloacal openings entering the medullar cavity since these lesions result from the introduction of pyogenic bacteria into the bone (Brothwell and Sandison 1967; Ortner and Putschar 1981; Steinbock 1976). Both kinds of infections were classified in two categories: "minor" if it involved less than one third of a bone or "extensive" if more than one third of the bone area was involved.
The data were processed using either bones or individuals as units of analysis. In this paper, due to space restrictions, we concentrate on the figures derived from using individuals as the unit of analysis. In this case two states for each individual were considered: affected or not affected. Only one infected bone was sufficient to consider the individual as affected. This approach has the advantage of considering the individual as a whole, avoiding fragmentation of data, since it is the individual and not the bone that becomes sick. On the other hand, this strategy has the disadvantage of not considering grades of infection. Taking into account this limitation, we also included an analysis using grades of infection. The percentage of bones infected per individual was calculated. These figures were used to generate a mean frequency for each period. Only infected individuals were included in this second strategy, and the four categories of infections were joined into one. Only sub-adults were processed in this case, since the data of adults we collected are not available to publication yet.
The analyses of adults and of sub-adults were done separately. In the case of the adults, data processing also included differences between sexes within each period.
Table 2 presents the prevalence of infectious disease in adults by sex for the four periods analyzed. Fisher’s Exact Test was applied to investigate the differences between sexes within each period. None of the comparisons reached statistical significance utilizing 5% p-value significance (data not shown).
Table 2. Incidence of nonspecific infectious diseases in adults by period and sex.
Incidencia de enfermedades infecciosas no-específicas en adultos por períodos y por sexo.
This result allows us to state that males and females were equally prone to bone infections throughout the four periods analyzed.
Table 3 presents the incidence for the four categories of bone infection by period with sexes pooled. The same information is graphically depicted in Figure 3. Table 4 presents the results of the sub-adults.
Table 3. Incidence of nonspecific infectious diseases in adults by period (sexes pooled).
Incidencia de enfermedades infecciosas no-específicas en adultos por períodos (sexos agrupados).
Figure 3. Incidence of nonspecific infectious diseases in adults by period.
Incidencia de enfermedades infecciosas no-específicas en adultos por períodos.
As can be seen, "minor periostitis" was, in general, the most frequent bone infection observed in San Pedro de Atacama, while "extensive osteomyelitis" was the least. This is in agreement with previous knowledge about these pathological lesions: localized periostitis can be easily produced by local wounds, while osteomyelitis demands either the rupture of the periosteum or a systemic infection in order to affect a bone (Brothwell and Sandison 1967; Goodman and Martin 2002; Larsen 1999; Ortner and Putschar 1981; Steinbock 1976).
Tables 3 and 5 and Figure 3 show a strong variation in the incidence of "minor periostitis" in adults among periods. With the exception of the comparison between pre-Tiwanaku and apex-Tiwanaku, all other comparisons reached statistical significance. In other words, the incidence during the apex influence of Tiwanaku did not change the picture when compared to the previous period. However, the apex influence period was followed by a significant decrease in the final-Tiwanaku phase. The high occurrence of bone infections in the post-Tiwanaku period is remarkable (Quitor-6) considering that almost 76% of the adult population was affected.
Tables 3 and 6 and Figure 3 show that the prevalence of "extensive periostitis" in adults was approximately the same from pre to final-Tiwanaku (no statistically significant differences were found when the three periods involved were compared). The post-Tiwanaku period witnessed a significant decrease in the incidence of this pathological lesion (differences attained statistical significance when compared with pre and final Tiwanaku). Considering that the prevalence of "minor" periostitis in the post-Tiwanaku period was high, the explanation for the decrease of "extensive" periostitis in that period remains uncertain. Although we could consider "minor" and "extensive" infections as different degrees of the same phenomenon, this relation, as can be seen here, is not so simple.
Tables 3 and 7 and Figure 3 show no significant difference in the occurrence of "minor osteomyelitis" in adults when pre-Tiwanaku and apex-Tiwanaku times are compared. Great changes in the frequencies of "minor osteomyelitis" occurred after the peak of Tiwanaku influence. Final-Tiwanaku presented a significant decrease in the rate of occurrence when compared with both apex-Tiwanaku and post-Tiwanaku (again, the most affected sample).
The extremely low frequencies of "extensive osteomyelitis" compared to other categories of infections in the adults of San Pedro de Atacama (Table 3 and Figure 3) suggest a strong resistance of the local population to pathogens leading to severe bone infections. The rate of occurrence of this category showed no significant difference among periods (Table 8).
The results with the sub-adults are similar to those of the adults (Table 4, Figure 4). "Minor periostitis" and "minor osteomyelitis" show a marked decrease in the final Tiwanaku. "Extensive periostitis" exhibits approximately the same pattern as the adults, with the exception of a decrease in the pre-Tiwanaku and an increase in the post-Tiwanaku period. As in the case of adults, "extensive osteomyelitis" presents the lowest frequencies of the four categories in sub-adults, although the values of pre and apex Tiwanaku in sub-adults are higher than in adults. None of the Exact Tests of Fisher performed among the periods (data not shown) produced significant results.
Table 4. Incidence of nonspecific infectious diseases in subadults by period.
Incidencia de enfermedades infecciosas no-específicas en subadultos por período.
Figure 4. Incidence of nonspecific infectious diseases in sub-adults by period.
Incidencia de enfermedades infecciosas no-específicas en subadultos por períodos.
The analysis of sub-adult skeletons using grades of infection is presented in Table 9 and Figure 5. They show the same basic pattern observed above: apex-Tiwanaku with the highest percentage (17.15%) and final Tiwanaku with the lowest (3.81%). The statistic test ANOVA no parametric (Kruskal-Wallis) did not produce a significant result using 5% p-value significance (Kw = 2.344; p-value = 0.5041). It is important to highlight, however, the similarity between the data for adults and sub-adults. This coincidence leads to a single pattern of infection, even with the lack of statistic significance for the sub-adults.
Figure 5. Percentage of infected bones per individual (mean) in sub-adults by period.
Porcentaje de huesos afectados por individuo (promedio) en subadultos por períodos.
Table 5. Comparison of incidence (adult skeletons) among periods by means of Fisher’s Exact Test (Minor Periostitis).
Comparación de la incidencia en esqueletos adultos entre períodos a través del Test Exacto de fisher (periostitis menor).
Table 6. Comparison of incidence (adult skeletons) among periods by means of Fisher’s Exact Test (Extensive Periostitis).
Comparación de la incidencia en esqueletos adultos entre períodos a través del Test Exacto de fisher (periostitis extensiva).
Table 7. Comparison of incidence (adult skeletons) among periods by means of Fisher’s Exact Test (Minor Osteomyelitis).
Comparación de la incidencia en esqueletos adultos entre períodos a través del Test Exacto de fisher (osteomielitis menor).
Table 8. Comparison of incidence (adult skeletons) among periods by means of Fisher’s Exact Test (Extensive Osteomyelitis).
Comparación de la incidencia en esqueletos adultos entre períodos, a través del Test Exacto de fisher (osteomielitis extensiva).
Table 9. Comparison of means (sub-adult skeletons) of bones affected by nonspecific infections among periods and respective samples.
Comparación de los promedios (esqueletos subdultos) de huesos afectados por enfermedades infecciosas no-específicas por períodos y respectivas muestras.
Discussion and Conclusions