On-line version ISSN 0717-7356
Chungará (Arica) vol.33 no.2 Arica July 2001
TOWARDS AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE INTERACTION OF HAIR WITH THE
*University of Bradford, Department of Archaeological Sciences, West Yorkshire BD7 1DP, Bradford, United Kingdom. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.
**University of Bradford, Department of Biomedical Sciences, West Yorkshire BD7 1DP, Bradford, United Kingdom.
***University of Bradford, Department of Chemical and Forensic Sciences, West Yorkshire BD7 1DP, Bradford, United Kingdom.
Key words: Scalp hair, degradation, contamination, microbial attack, TEM, FT-Raman Spectroscopy
Existe un gran interés en el uso analítico del pelo humano de contextos arqueológicos en áreas claves de investigación como los análisis de ADN, elementos traza e isótopos. Otros tejidos humanos, especialmente el hueso, que han sido usados para los análisis de ADN, elementos químicos e isótopos, han sido estudiados en relación a su diagénesis, pero esto no se ha realizado en pelo. Es necesario considerar la compleja interacción entre el pelo y el ambiente del entierro, creando así una base firme para el uso de éste en futuras investigaciones. A causa de que el pelo humano sobrevive bajo un rango diverso de condiciones ambientales, un estudio piloto ha investigado los procesos básicos de la degradación del pelo usando muestras de distintas zonas climáticas y tipos diferentes de entierros. La variación en el grado de preservación del pelo arqueológico fue caracterizada por microscopía de luz, microscopía de scanner electrónico y espectroscopía FT-Raman, relacionando el cambio morfológico de la superficie y la estructura interna con su integridad bioquímica. Los resultados demuestran una desintegración de los bordes de células corticales y la ruptura de las capas cuticulares, junto a la infiltración de materia de la matriz del entierro, que sugiere una pérdida progresiva de cohesión que se debe parcialmente a actividad microbiológica. El pelo medulado demuestra ser más susceptible a desintegración física dado que provee dos rutas para el ataque microbial y ambiental. Al nivel molecular, el componente proteico pasa por alteración, y se pierden las conexiones de S-S cystine que son responsables de la fuerza y elasticidad del pelo en individuos vivos.
Palabras claves: Cuero cabelludo, degradación, contaminación, microorganismos, espectroscopía FT Raman.
Despite the early work by Trotter (Trotter 1943) who examined the hair of mummies from the Paracas Peninsula, Brothwell and Spearman (Brothwell 1963) were the first to examine hair from a range of archaeological environments. In recent years a renewed interest in archaeological hair has been fueled by advances in analytical techniques, allowing reconstruction of diet (Pain 1998), analysis of drug use, genetics (Bonnichsen 1996) etc. Yet the degree of preservation of ancient hair samples has not been subject to the same scrutiny as for archaeological bone. Already several investigations using hair of variable con
dition have produced results inconsistent with other types of archaeological evidence (Wilson submitted-a).
Hair survives in diverse archaeological environments, yet it is not found universally. The fact that hair degrades means that the complex interaction of hair with its depositional environment must be considered - thereby laying a firm basis for the use of hair in future research. The systematic investigation of hair degradation is fundamental to all hair research (Cartmell personal communication). Readers are referred to Ryder (1973) for a basic introduction to hair morphology and structure.
At Bradford University we are engaged in a multidisciplinary study examining variation in sample condition from diverse archaeological, forensic and museum environments. A pilot project examined human terminal scalp hair from 13 disparate contexts (Table 1). The degree of preservation of each sample was characterized by light microscopy, electron microscopy and FT-Raman spectroscopy - relating morphological change of the surface and internal structure of hair to its biochemical integrity.
Scanning electron microscopy was used to determine the external condition of individual fibres. Progressive changes to the cuticle along the hair shaft were consistent with weathering in life. More dramatic changes such as total loss of cuticle, separation of individual cortical cell bundles (fibrillation) and the presence of holes and erosion of the cortex characteristic of fungal tunneling highlighted the potentially aggressive nature of the depositional environment. However, adherent deposits such as clay or fungal hyphae frequently obscured the surface, so cross-sectional information was sought. Fibres were fixed and embedded prior to thin-sectioning. Transverse sections (tip, midshaft and root ends) were examined by light microscopy (0.5 (m thick sections) and transmission electron microscopy (100 nm thick sections).
Considerable variation in survival of internal morphology was noted at the inter-site level. Thin-sections confirmed that outwardly a fibre may appear normal, with the potential for the external cuticle to be retained, whilst the underlying cortex and medulla were disrupted. The tip and root ends of the fibres examined were more prone to degradative change than the midshaft, highlighting a crucial sampling issue.
Selective degradation -correspondant with the relative resistance of internal hair structures (Wilson 1999a) - resulted in differential loss of cell membrane complex [the lipid-protein-lipid boundary membrane between individual cortical cells] and progressive loss of cohesion between individual macrofibrils with an overall increase in porosity. At one extreme pigment granules and remnant exocuticle were all that survived with highly degraded samples. More recently, fibres recovered from experimental burial sites show similar morphological changes to the results of this pilot study (Wilson in preparation).
Extreme depositional environments may produce characteristic effects such as those noted with extreme desiccation. At the gross level, fibres from sample H101 were severely shrunken and embrittled. Thin sections showed a highly altered morphology with the only recognizable structures being shrunken pigment granules and cuspate cuticle.
Concomitant with the differential loss of parts of the cortex and the correspondent increase in porosity is the potential for influx of contaminants. Iron corrosion salts were distributed throughout the porous degraded root section of sample H083 from an iron coffin burial (Figure 1). FT-Raman spectroscopy provided confirmation that deposition of exogenous contaminants is particularly influenced by burial mode. The presence of carbonates in three samples [H159, H170, H173] relates to their depositional environments. Two came from lead-lined coffins and one came from a limestone cave. FT-Raman microscopy of fibre cross-sections confirmed that these were not simply surface deposits.
Figure 1. Transmission electron micrograph showing transverse root ultra-thin section of porous degraded hair sample [H083] with infiltrated contaminants distributed throughout the cortex. Scale: 0.7mm
Key: m - macrofibril
Dark circular structures - pigment granules
Dark diffuse stained regions - infiltrated material from the burial environment
FT-Raman spectroscopy (Edwards 1998) was used to confirm the progressive nature of biochemical alteration to hair fibres. Breakdown of the protein structure and conversion of the structural disulphide linkages in cystine to cysteic acid and intermediate states suggested that partial oxidation may occur. The cleavage of disulphide bonds in hair may relate to specific changes due to the decomposition of a body. In an enclosed environment, e.g. a lead coffin environment, these effects may by magnified (Wilson 1999b).
The results of this study highlighted the problems of reliance solely on assessment of sample surface condition. The importance of a multidisciplinary approach is stressed, with use of a combination of suitable test controls. The critical need for assessment of hair degradation in archaeological investigations is now acknowledged (Coghlan 1999).
Recibido: agosto 1999. Aceptado: diciembre 2000.
Bonnichsen, R., M.T. Beatty, M. D. Turner and M. Stoneking 1996 What Can Be Learned From Hair? A Hair Record From The Mammoth Meadow Locus, Southwestern Montana. In Prehistoric Mongoloid Dispersals, Oxford Science Publications, edited by T. Akazawa and E. J. E. Zathmary, pp. 201-213. Oxford. [ Links ]
Brothwell, D. S. R. 1963 The Hair of Earlier Peoples. In Science in Archaeolo gy, 1st Edn. edited by D. H. Brothwell, E. Thames and Hudson, pp. 427-436. Bristol. [ Links ]
Coghlan, A. 1999 Hair Today...Do Ancient Locks Provide Reliable Clues o our Ancestors' Diets. New Scientist 16th October: 24. [ Links ]
Edwards, H. G. M., D.W. Farwell and A. S. Wilson 1998 The Degradation of Human Hair Studied by FT-Raman Spectroscopy. Proceedings of the XVIth International Conference on Raman Spectroscopy (ICORS '98), pp. 540-541.Cape Town, South Africa. [ Links ]
Pain, S.1998 Beyond the Fringe. New Scientist 12th December: 34-37. [ Links ]
Ryder, M. L. 1973 Hair. Studies in Biology 41, London, Institute of Biology. [ Links ]
Trotter, M. 1943 Hair from Paracas Indian Mummies. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 1: 69-75. [ Links ]
Wilson, A. S., R. C. Janaway, and D. J.Tobin, 1999a Effect of the Burial Environment on Hair Shaft Morphology - Relevance for Archaeology and Medico-legal Investigations. Journal of Investigative Dermatology - Symposium Proceedings 4:353 [ Links ]
Wilson, A. S., H. G. M. Edwards, D.W. Farwell and R. C. Janaway 1999b Fourier Transform Raman Spectroscopy: Evaluation as a Non-Destructive Technique for Studying the Degradation of Human Hair from Archaeological and Forensic Environments. Journal of Raman Spectroscopy 30: 367-373. [ Links ]
Wilson, A. S., R. A. Dixon, R. C. Janaway, A. M. Pollard and D. J. Tobin Digging the Dirt on Hair Degradation. Biologist, in preparation. [ Links ]
Wilson, A. S., R. C., Janaway, A. M., Pollard, R. A. Dixon and D. J. Tobin Submitted-a Survival of Human Hair - The Impact of the Burial Environment. in editors to be confirmed, Proceedings Human Remains, Conservation, Retrieval and Analysis, Colonial Williamsburg, Virginia [ Links ]